« Halverson/Hardcastle matter featured in ABA Journal | Main | In the news »

Nevada Commission on Judicial Discipline suspends Judge Halverson

The Nevada Supreme Court notes that the Nevada Commission on Judicial Discipline entered a final order of interim suspension today, Juyly 25, 2007, with respect to Judge Elizabeth Halverson. The Court finds that the Order is a public document.

The 29-page order provides that Judge Halverson is suspended from the exercise of office pending a final determination of judicial discipline proceedings. My brief review of the order reveals the following:

at pg. 8 - The Commission concludes that the Special Counsel must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that interim suspension is warranted, considering the totality of the circumstances.

at pg. 10 - The Commission offers a justification for its decision to deny Judge Halverson's request to issue subpoenaes to 7 witnesses and to make document production requests of those witnesses.

at pg. 12 - The Commission explains that Judge Halverson was not harmed by the late delivery of certain documents because she was not entitled to them at this stage of the proceedings.

at pg. 14 - the Commission notes its findings which led it to makes its initial order of interm suspension. It made 6 findings based upon the complaint. Based upon the evidence presented at the hearing by the Special Counsel and Judge Halverson at the July 16th hearing, the Commission finds that there was sufficient proof only as to items 1, 2, 3 and 5:

Additional details are set forth below the jump:

1. There is substantial evidence to believe that Judge Halverson is without sufficient legal abilities to conduct trials in criminal cases without threat of serious harm to the public or the administration of justice;
2. There is substantial evidence to believe that Judge Halverson has failed to perform the duties of judicial office impartially and diligently in that there is substantial evidence that she has not treated staff and litigants with patience, dignity or courtesy. Further, there is substantial evidence that she has treated staff to a hostile work environment and sexual harassment to the extent that there is a serious threat to the administration of justice;
3. There is substantial evidence that Judge Halverson has failed to diligently perform her duties by falling asleep at least on one occasion and possible more while on the bench during a jury trial;
5. There is substantial evidence to believe that Judge Halverson failed to diligently carry out the duties of her office and fail[ed] to cooperate with other judges and court administrators[.]

pg. 15 - The Commission discusses testimony introduced at the hearing. Issues addressed included ex parte contact with jurors and assignment of only civil cases by Chief Judge Hardcastle.

pg. 17 - The Commission notes the high number of peremptory challenges against Judge Halverson in civil cases and indicates that this reveals an unease about her ability to handle civil matters.

pg. 18 - "While the Commission believes that Judge Halverson's handling of criminal matters is troublesome to the point of warranting suspension, the Commission also believes that her handling of personnel matters is even more problematic." Details of allegations by court personnel are set forth at length. If the allegations are true, it's not good.

pg.21 - The Commission notes a pattern of dictatorial and domineering behavior toward staff members

pg. 22 - The Commission notes the possibility of state or county liability for acts of racial, religious and sexual insensitivity and possible other tortious acts.

pg. 23 - The allegation of sleeping in court constitutes a partial basis for the interim suspension

pg. 24 - Sufficient proof exists to support the claim that Judge Halverson failed to cooperate with other judges and court administrators.

pg. 26 - Judge Halverson is suspended on an interim basis, with pay. The order is effective as of 5 p.m. today.

Comments

Vegas Judge Halverson asked bailiff to �shoot� ex-felon husband �Evil Ed� then offered to dispose of the body.

http://www.abajournal.com/news/bailiff_tells_of_judges_shooting_remarks/

Judiciary
Bailiff Tells of Judge�s Shooting Remarks
Posted 1 hour, 44 minutes ago
By Debra Cassens Weiss

The ex-bailiff for controversial Las Vegas Judge Elizabeth Halverson testified that she frequently asked him to shoot her husband, according to recently released transcripts.

Johnnie Jordan said Halverson often made the remarks in front her husband, an ex-felon she called �evil Ed,� the Las Vegas Review-Journal reports. But her spouse wasn�t present on one occasion when she said she would help dispose of the body, Jordan testified (PDF).

Jordan said he didn�t take the shooting remarks as a joke. �I didn�t know how to take it,� he said.

Jordan also said Halverson fell asleep every day in court. He claimed the judge, who used a scooter, made him put on her shoes, clean the lint off her robe, keep fresh ice water and heat her lunch in the microwave.

If he didn�t perform these duties to the judge�s satisfaction, she �hollered and was very aggressive,� Jordan said. He said he has filed racial discrimination and sexual harassment complaints against the judge.

The Nevada Commission on Judicial Discipline issued an interim order late last month that suspended Halverson with pay. The commission found the judge poses a threat of harm to the administration of justice, citing her inexperience and poor judgment.

Halverson has appealed the suspension. Her lawyers claim the hearing "lacked due process and was fundamentally unfair."

STORIES FROM ABA JOURNAL ALONE:

6 Results for HALVERSON
� ABA Journal Daily News
Bailiff Tells of Judge�s Shooting Remarks
1 hour, 55 minutes ago

The ex-bailiff for controversial Las Vegas Judge Elizabeth Halverson testified that she frequently asked him to shoot her husband, according to recently released transcripts. Johnnie Jordan said Halverson often made the remarks in front her husband, an ex-felon she called �evil Ed,� the Las Vegas Review-Journal reports. But her spouse�
http://www.abajournal.com/news/bailiff_tells_of_judges_shooting_remarks/

� Magazine
You�re NOT the Boss of Me
Aug 1, 2007, 06:26 am CDT

But just a few flips into the hundreds of pages of pleadings, exhibits and affidavits�including formerly confidential documents circulated among judges, ad�ministrators and staff�there is a nasty battle involving a newly elected judge who figuratively turned the courthouse upside down, then literally got banned from it and locked out. Las�
http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/youre_not_the_boss_of_me/

� ABA Journal Daily News
Nev. Judge to Appeal Suspension
Jul 27, 2007, 03:28 pm CDT

The lawyer for controversial Las Vegas Judge Elizabeth Halverson promises an appeal of her interim suspension. William Gamage did not offer comment on the details of his client�s case, the Las Vegas Review-Journal reports. The suspension will remain in effect pending a decision on whether to formally charge the judge�
http://www.abajournal.com/news/nev_judge_to_appeal_suspension/

� ABA Journal Daily News
Nev. Judge Suspended, Poses �Substantial Threat,� Commission Finds
Jul 25, 2007, 07:55 pm CDT

A controversial Nevada judge was suspended today by the state Commission on Judicial Discipline, which found that Elizabeth Halverson "poses a substantial threat of serious harm" to the public and the administration of justice. In a final order of interim suspension filed today, the commission suspended the judge with pay,�
http://www.abajournal.com/news/judge_halverson_suspended_in_nev_flap/

� ABA Journal Daily News
Observers Agog Over Nev. Judge Saga
Jul 25, 2007, 01:25 pm CDT

Halfway into her first year on the bench, Clark County District Judge Elizabeth Halverson is one of the best-known jurists in Nevada. Although a law school classmate praises her as an attorney capable of Harvard Law Review-quality work, it isn't her legal intellect that's attracting all the attention. Instead, Halverson�
http://www.abajournal.com/news/observers_agog_over_nev_judge_saga/

� ABA Journal Daily News
Rookie Judge Reportedly Investigated
Jun 5, 2007, 10:59 am CDT

A rookie Las Vegas judge who is fighting the chief judge�s effort to remove her is reportedly under investigation by a judicial conduct commission. Anonymous sources told the Las Vegas Sun that the Nevada Commission on Judicial Discipline is investigating Judge Elizabeth Halverson, accused of acting abusively toward her staff�

Here's anothe about Judge Halverson

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)